26 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

rlm wrote:

I'd say it was due to lack of unique content more than anything.  It can't be just a duplicate of the same content at another forum. Getting key contributors to forego posting elsewhere is the deal breaker.

Yes, remember it's MapleDots you're talking to, I am the king of starting topics. I stopped at DNF because it was pointless with all the closed topics.

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

27 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

rlm wrote:

I'll post a similar good-bye message at the other place.  I'll leave a few breadcrumbs on my way out the door.

They filter out dn.ca and it replaces with rule_violation - what a bunch of nimrods!!

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

28 Reply by: rlm

  • rlm
  • rlm
  • Trusted
  • Online
  • Location: BC
  • Joined: Nov 07, 2020
  • Posts: 660
  • Likes: 432

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

MapleDots wrote:

They filter out dn.ca and it replaces with rule_violation - what a bunch of nimrods!!

yep, I saw that too.  But dn(dot)ca works.

Liked by: RedRider, MapleDots

29 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

rlm wrote:

While I appreciate that offer, I prefer to not moderate.  For one, I'd have to moderate myself.  I just got spanked at namepros for berating a really stupid .CA post.  Sometimes a post is so egregious I can't help myself and it was well worth the spanking I knew I'd get from a moderator.  Plus, I don't like committing to anything.  If I want to go dark for 3 months, I don't want to feel guilty about it.  And as a moderator I'd feel less inclined to add content.  Content is king, not moderation.

Moderation here will be easy, we are polite Canadians and I hope we can gently guide people instead of forcing moderation on them. That is why at 100 posts they become trusted members. I might even put on member guides or something, anything except heavy handed moderation.

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

30 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

And as far as quitting other forums, I basically did that, if they won't let me talk about true Canadian topics like DN.ca then why should I post there?

Tell me what is the difference...

1. A blog posts an article on their blog.
2. Opens a topic on namepros
3. Posts a piece of the topic with a link back to the blog.
4. On the blog members discuss it.

I was in a long conversation with Eric Lyon and told him our forum is no different and linking back and forth creates traffic for everyone. I told him I understood why they banned DNForum.com but we are no competition because we are like a blog about .ca's only. I said we should become a partner site but all he said is he will think about it. Next I know rule_violation pops up anywhere dn.ca is mentioned.

If he is going to be like that I think asking our members to support this forum instead of namepros is warranted.

I hope I can get DomainRecap to moderate the TBR section here, he does such a good job it's too bad everything is hidden at namepros. I would give him free reign in TBR and would never interfere with any topic, he would have exclusive mod rights in that forum unless HE designated a helper.

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

Liked by: RedRider

31 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

rlm wrote:

yep, I saw that too.  But dn(dot)ca works.

You will get your hands slapped if someone reports you.

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

32 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

rlm wrote:

Feedback:

The one thing I did like at the other place is the "Like Dislike Thank Agree Disagree" options. There are times when each of those are appropriate, it gives feedback to the poster and as well as the public, and I like the idea that it can be used to create a credibility score of the poster.  Not that i've seen it be necessary very often, but occasionally some troll will pop up and flood the place with stupidity, and if a poster gets beat down enough with a bad like/dislike agree/disagree ratio, you can rate limit posts based on their negative scores.  Its essentially a way to allow the public to moderate.

However, I think you'd have to have a very busy forum to make a public-moderation scheme like that useful.  Primarily I just like those "Like Dislike Thank Agree Disagree" options as a low resistance way to give feedback without having to make such a trivial post like "i agree".  And I like that people can disagree/dislike too without actually making a more in-your-face post saying that.

I have thanks activated, it puts a thanks link under your profile picture for every post. A member can thank or take it away. In your profile it show how many thanks the member has.

I have another more elaborate one planned but that might take a bit so lets us this basic one for a spell.

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

Liked by: LovelyLynda

33 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

PS, I will probably be switching the word "Thanks" with "Like"

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

Liked by: RedRider, LovelyLynda

34 Reply by: LovelyLynda

  • LovelyLynda
  • LovelyLynda
  • Member
  • Online
  • Location: London, ON
  • Joined: Nov 10, 2020
  • Posts: 39
  • Likes: 11

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

MapleDots wrote:

PS, I will probably be switching the word "Thanks" with "Like"

I see like not thanks??

*KISSED*

LovelyLynda's Website

35 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

LovelyLynda wrote:

I see like not thanks??

I did that one myself Lynda, I know how to edit the language files.

If anyone has a better suggestion for the wording let me know.

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

Liked by: RedRider, LovelyLynda

36 Reply by: RedRider

  • RedRider
  • RedRider
  • Member
  • Online
  • Location: Mississauga, ON
  • Joined: Nov 06, 2020
  • Posts: 103
  • Likes: 35

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

I just noticed the new like feature

Very nice!


https://i.postimg.cc/Hxc8wkrp/thumb.jpg

37 Reply by: rlm

  • rlm
  • rlm
  • Trusted
  • Online
  • Location: BC
  • Joined: Nov 07, 2020
  • Posts: 660
  • Likes: 432

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

MapleDots wrote:

I hope I can get DomainRecap to moderate the TBR section here, he does such a good job it's too bad everything is hidden at namepros. I would give him free reign in TBR and would never interfere with any topic, he would have exclusive mod rights in that forum unless HE designated a helper.

Well maybe you'll get your wish.  I asked him if he can hear his own echo after he makes a post over there.  It's either that or crickets.  I told him to come join us, he said in a couple days, sounds like he's super busy right now.

Liked by: jaydub, MapleDots

38 Reply by: rlm

  • rlm
  • rlm
  • Trusted
  • Online
  • Location: BC
  • Joined: Nov 07, 2020
  • Posts: 660
  • Likes: 432

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

How come I don't see any "like" options on posts?  It sounds like some already see that option?

Liked by: MapleDots

39 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

rlm wrote:

How come I don't see any "like" options on posts?  It sounds like some already see that option?

For this post look under your post stats.

I liked your post, look at the bottom of the post as well.

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

40 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

rlm wrote:

Well maybe you'll get your wish.  I asked him if he can hear his own echo after he makes a post over there.  It's either that or crickets.  I told him to come join us, he said in a couple days, sounds like he's super busy right now.

Well, they just notified me that they deleted my good bye post in that section.

I am now officially done on namepros, I will no longer tolerate the totalitarian moderating there.

If that ever happens here I will resign and let better moderators run the board.

I have to shake my head, I just cannot believe the amount of deletions on that forum.
As Canadians do we really want to post our .ca discussion on an American board that deletes posts and topics at an epic pace?

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website

41 Reply by: rlm

  • rlm
  • rlm
  • Trusted
  • Online
  • Location: BC
  • Joined: Nov 07, 2020
  • Posts: 660
  • Likes: 432

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

MapleDots wrote:

For this post look under your post stats.

I liked your post, look at the bottom of the post as well.

Ah yes, I'm so used to seeing it under the post, I didn't look over there.  But to be honest, its not intuitive to put post-related content (i.e. reactions like/agree/thanks/etc to a specific post) in the profile-related content section.

42 Reply by: MapleDots

  • MapleDots
  • MapleDots
  • Board Admin
  • Online
  • Location: Waterloo, ON
  • Joined: Nov 04, 2020
  • Posts: 1,678
  • Likes: 769

Re: Editing for Trusted Members

rlm wrote:

Ah yes, I'm so used to seeing it under the post, I didn't look over there.  But to be honest, its not intuitive to put post-related content (i.e. reactions like/agree/thanks/etc to a specific post) in the profile-related content section.

namepros had their system custom written and it probably cost a small fortune. I looked at Xenforo and their system is not nearly as good as namepros. Our board software does not come with a like system, everything is a customization and this was the best I could do for now. I might address it again in the future but right now it will have to do.

On the pro side our post count is live. Delete it takes one off and place a post it adds one. Usually the software does not deduct a post on deletion.

Additionally its fun to give and take a thanks because you can see it adjust the other members number live so you know it works.

dn.ca/topic/8/mapledots

MapleDots's Website