We use privacy from a another provider. I have looked at the privacy (and potential cost to switch some of our domain-related suppliers), and it's not likely something we'll be changing anytime soon. I also have a pretty good idea of what other providers there are and what they charge.
ICANN also has plans to require a separate type of accreditation for whois privacy providers, but the project has stalled for a while. I was part of an initial working group from the registrars' side.
Not sure I understand this correctly. Would you want to use another privacy service that isn't part of your registrar? That privacy service would be listed as the owner of your domain in the whois. At least for gTLDs, the underlying ownership data would be stored with the Registrar Data Escrow service. If you're using a 3rd party service the information of the original owner might get lost.
No it's all good, just thinking out loud wondering if an all Canadian wholesale privacy provider would be a decent business idea. Then resell the privacy to hosting companies so whois shows a Canadian privacy address.
I mean if WHC has to farm it out to a US company that means there has to be a hole there somewhere for an innovative Canadian competitor right?
I have posted about this elsewhere and @FM has alluded to it above, the data we have as the registry from our perspective is the data provided to us by the registrar. If you choose to use a third party privacy service then that service is the bona fide owner of your domains. You are entrusting the management of your domains to them.
And, again as stated elsewhere, CIRA provides WHOIS privacy for any "individual" by default.
Sponsors who contribute to keep dn.ca free for everyone.