But it's a .ca domain, low international recognition (1.Viewing)

Active Topics New Topic
MapleDots

MapleDotsMapleDots is verified member.

MapleDots.ca
Community Guide
Joined
Nov 2, 2020
All Topics
2,037
Posts
8,424
Likes
7,205
From
Waterloo, ON
Country flag
Got someone going back and forth on a .ca with me and the guy is low balling me. I usually just ignore but during the back and forth he made this comment.

But it's a .ca domain, low international recognition
Click to expand...

I responded asking him if he is kidding or if he even understands domains.

1. .ca means Canada, everyone in the world recognizes that.

2. Recognition in Canada is the highest there is.

3. Why is he worried about international recognition buying a .ca ?


The statement is weird from every angle, it's like negotiating on a .de and complaining it's not an international domain. I don't think the guy even understands the concept of a ccTLD.
 
Had this conversation many times over the past 25 years and it is to intimidate the registrant.

I have heard people say “it’s only a Canadian domain” “it’s good for only 30M people” etc
 
Of course they're just trying to knock you down, they've got nothing to lose. But it does indicate they are actually interested in acquiring the domain. Some potential buyers are just small-time and will never be able to afford the domain, but others CAN afford the domain, they just dont WANT to pay for it. I have converted some of those types into very good sales.

So assuming this is a nice premium domain name, I would say:

If the .CA domain will not achieve your business goals, then no problem. If you need non-Canadian exposure, then .COM is indeed king. In that case, I absolutely recommend that you price it out and make that purchase if it fits your budget. If you primarily need Canadian exposure, or you are proud to show the international market that your products and/or services are Canadian based, then only the .CA will do that. .CA is the undisputed king of Canada, just as most other country code TLDs (known as ccTLDs) are for their respective countries. Note that even if you acquire the .com, the .CA is still a necessity if you're marketing to Canadians, for all of the obvious reasons. Other TLD's carry significant risk, so if you're seriously considering some other TLD extension, then please do your research first.

I'd also like to point out that if I were willing to sell this domain as cheap as you'd like, then the domain would have already been sold long ago and you wouldn't even have this opportunity to purchase it right now. You should THANK me that the price isn't cheap. That's the reality here.

If you would truly like to acquire this domain, then please understand that your budget may dictate what you can afford right now, but it does not dictate the domain's value. Our pricing is based on 20 years of .CA specific domain sales experience. It ensures that this domain will eventually go to a business that can truly take advantage of the long-term branding and financial benefits of having the perfect .CA domain name. Premium domain names such as this bring with it a premium aura that includes giving your business instant trust and respect, and it is priced as such.

So if you do understand the long term value of owning this domain name, then maybe the best solution is to discuss financing options. A payment plan has a lot of advantages, including:

- You get immediate use of your perfect domain name.
- Build your brand now, it is less costly than a brand change later.
- You ensure the domain doesn't get sold to anyone else.
- You lock in the price and avoid future price increases.
- Less cash up front that can be used for growing the business.
- Consider it a try-it-before-you-buy-it scenario, less upfront risk.
- You can cancel any time, with no commitment.

I have much more flexibility over the terms of the payment plan than the price of the domain. I would suggest that we accept your offer as a down-payment and work out payment terms for the remaining amount due. Would this work for you?
 
Just got this one. Can't believe a broker would even lead with an offer like this. But I guess they got paid to do it and a nice low offer like this just means they won't have to even deal with a response.

Hi Sir/Mam, I'm contacting you today from GoDaddy's Domain Broker Team because we have a Buyer interested in purchasing your domain -------------.CA. Please let me know if you are interested in selling this domain, and what your asking price would be. Our potential buyer has provided the following initial offer: OFFER AMOUNT: $200 USD (buyer pays all broker fees) If you would like me to present a counter-offer to our buyer, or accept this initial offer please let me know. Your prompt consideration would be greatly appreciated. I look forward to speaking with you soon. Best Regards, James
 
rlm said:
Just got this one. Can't believe a broker would even lead with an offer like this. But I guess they got paid to do it and a nice low offer like this just means they won't have to even deal with a response.

Hi Sir/Mam, I'm contacting you today from GoDaddy's Domain Broker Team because we have a Buyer interested in purchasing your domain -------------.CA. Please let me know if you are interested in selling this domain, and what your asking price would be. Our potential buyer has provided the following initial offer: OFFER AMOUNT: $200 USD (buyer pays all broker fees) If you would like me to present a counter-offer to our buyer, or accept this initial offer please let me know. Your prompt consideration would be greatly appreciated. I look forward to speaking with you soon. Best Regards, James
Click to expand...
Pretty standard GoDaddy broker service offer.

Some brokers will try to talk sense into buyers, however at the end of the day they will present a $100 offer for Gold.com if the buyer insists. They are being paid to do it.

As the process goes on, you will start to get the "offers are rare" emails.

Don't forget when GeorgeK @GeorgeK missed out on the once in a lifetime opportunity to sell Bling.com for $20K. 🤣

That was a "great offer" according to the broker.

Brad
 
DataCube said:
Pretty standard GoDaddy broker service offer.

Some brokers will try to talk sense into buyers, however at the end of the day they will present a $100 offer for Gold.com if the buyer insists. They are being paid to do it.

As the process goes on, you will start to get the "offers are rare" emails.

Don't forget when GeorgeK @GeorgeK missed out on the once in a lifetime opportunity to sell Bling.com for $20K. 🤣

That was a "great offer" according to the broker.

Brad
Click to expand...
Oh I know, I get lots of them. It just astounds me that they think they'll get a reply. And I guess that is the point I was making, they probably don't want a reply. They know they've got a buyer who's just going to waste their time.
 
.ca can be seized by Canadian government if you say wrong things (their determination), .com not, many new Canadians not sure what .ca is, is becoming "international country", this adds to less value
 
akbar said:
.ca can be seized by Canadian government if you say wrong things (their determination)
Click to expand...
That is actually incorrect


akbar said:
not, many new Canadians not sure what .ca is
Click to expand...
If one knows what a .in is then one knows what a .ca is.
Since most new immigrants in Canada are from India, they are already familiar with a cctld.


Ps. Welcome aboard (y)
 
MapleDots said:
That is actually incorrect

If one knows what a .in is then one knows what a .ca is.
Since most new immigrants in Canada are from India, they are already familiar with a cctld.

Ps. Welcome aboard (y)
Click to expand...
It sounds like .CA is seized in the way most extensions are, including .COM, via court order.

Outside that, can you give an example where a .CA domain was seized for "saying the wrong things" without due process? akbar @akbar

This is what Google says -

The .ca registry, managed by the Canadian Internet Registration Authority (CIRA), can seize domains, but only under specific circumstances, such as a Canadian court order or judgment, or in accordance with their Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy.

  • Legal Basis for Seizure:
    The Canadian government can seize ".ca" domain names through court orders, provided the alleged offenses warrant it.
  • Examples of Seizure:
    Domain seizures are typically ordered in association with criminal acts, such as cybercrime, fraud, and money laundering.
 
akbar said:
I am stating my opinion. This is why people low ball .ca.
Click to expand...

Well it just seemed funny that your first post on a .CA forum was slagging .CA.

But, you don't think people lowball .com too?? I got a $4000 offer on a 1-word .com this week and he was white as Wonder Bread.

As sellers we should put up BIN prices and minimum offers or otherwise fully expect to get low balls. If I walked into a store with no prices (and I don't care if its a McDonalds or a car dealership), I'm sure as hell going to lowball too. That's what we get for not putting up price guidance. That is why people low ball, not because they are immigrants.

And along with MapleDots @MapleDots sentiments, I don't think that any Canadian immigrant savvy enough to want to buy a domain name is ignorant enough to not know about the relevance of .CA to Canadians. And even if you're opinion had some validity in relation to immigrants specifically, it would still affect only a small portion of overall lowballs received.
 
rlm said:
Well it just seemed funny that your first post on a .CA forum was slagging .CA.

But, you don't think people lowball .com too?? I got a $4000 offer on a 1-word .com this week and he was white as Wonder Bread.

As sellers we should put up BIN prices and minimum offers or otherwise fully expect to get low balls. If I walked into a store with no prices (and I don't care if its a McDonalds or a car dealership), I'm sure as hell going to lowball too. That's what we get for not putting up price guidance. That is why people low ball, not because they are immigrants.

And along with MapleDots @MapleDots sentiments, I don't think that any Canadian immigrant savvy enough to want to buy a domain name is ignorant enough to not know about the relevance of .CA to Canadians. And even if you're opinion had some validity in relation to immigrants specifically, it would still affect only a small portion of overall lowballs received.
Click to expand...
Immigrants are smart that is why they know value isnt much for country domain. And same situation as corona + bank account freezes can happen to anyone. If Mr. Musk had tesla.ca you really don't think they have found a way to freeze or hijack it because of current situation
little guys at cira have no real power. Be real Canadian government operates likethis. .com they can't do nothing. That's my point. Immigrants are smart they know. And you can take .com back home .ca no
 
Indians do have half assed shit jobs on everything, why should domaining be any different. :poop:
 

Sponsors who contribute to keep dn.ca free for everyone.

Sponsor
CanSpace
CIRA
FullHost
NameNinja
WHC
Donors

Sponsors who contribute to keep dn.ca free.

Members who recently read this topic: 32

Back
Top Bottom