So how did WHC, with a lot of high picks, get such a bad APP number? Well, they happened to win all the picks from 48-60 straight.
Those weren't "first round picks". Those were second round picks that got "promoted" (into the first 5 second window) because they botched the first round timing. Anything that comes in just ahead of the 5.0 second mark is a sign of a thread that got a "too early" response "5 seconds" earlier.
00:04.922 WHC/Sibername mosquitocontrol.ca
00:04.924 WHC/Sibername smallbusinessnetwork.ca
00:04.926 WHC/Sibername mayada.ca
00:04.930 WHC/Sibername inmemory.ca
00:04.932 WHC/Sibername substrate.ca
00:04.932 WHC/Sibername 5days.ca
00:04.956 MyID fraserview.ca
00:04.959 MyID truckloads.ca
00:04.970 Catchdrop booktickets.ca
00:04.970 WHC/Sibername pattys.ca
00:04.973 WHC/Sibername aiventures.ca
00:04.974 WHC/Sibername nyra.ca
00:04.974 WHC/Sibername berkey.ca
00:04.974 WHC/Sibername numismatic.ca
00:04.974 WHC/Sibername gowns.ca
00:04.974 WHC/Sibername herongate.ca
00:04.974 WHC/Sibername showpro.ca
00:04.974 MyID salesagent.ca
00:04.987 WHC/Sibername causewaybayhotels.ca
00:04.989 WHC/Sibername bendy.ca
00:04.993 WHC/Sibername r2ohome.ca
00:04.993 WHC/Sibername freemarketplace.ca
so that 00:04.922 timestamp, means that thread came in before 11:59:59.922 on the previous try ... and at this point they're no longer hunting premium names, so the success rate skyrockets.