Atom = waste of time for .ca (7.Viewing)

Their .CA domain valuations have totally gone to shit. I just ran through about a dozen of my past sales through their appraisal tool and I would have lost over $2M in revenue from just those sales had I sold at their valuations. Even the recent sales mentioned here for Shop.ca and Pay.ca had valuations of only around $12K each. Their valuations are now more like a wholesale value, prices you'd pay for these domains in TBR.

So how are you going to sell a domain like Pay.ca for $500K through Atom when they're happy to tell your buyer that they only value the domain at $12K ???

no .ca sales data means lower appraisals. They sell so much .ai domains, even bad ones get good appraisals.

Everyone says afternic is bleeding to spaceship. I think Atom is actually doing the most bleeding to spaceship on a percentage of listings basis.

I can agree that Atom recently dropped the appraisal value of .CA domains through the floor. In your account there is a Portfolio Valuation number and one day out of the blue, mine just dropped by around 25%, and further investigation showed my .CAs were the only domains contributing to that loss.

I'd estimate maybe a 35% overall drop in .CA values hit sometime in August.